Crush It!

As I noted in another post yesterday about Covid for some reason we think the worst is over, no its ongoing everyday.  Largely why? Because we have a Government indifferent to the reality of this, States and Municipalities trying to figure it out from Governors who are sure they have the right team, crew, input from the same afraid, ignorant or slightly more knowledgeable medical staff who for all ostensible purposes have actually never been in the field during a pandemic. And those that have been are relegated to the sidelines, not called to action, to devise a cohesive, comprehensive plan and more importantly find a clear messenger who can communicate with the public in a fashion that evokes both concern and hope that this will too come to an end.

For awhile here in the tri-state area we had the Three Amigos, Cuomo, DiBlasio and Murphy. After a week or two I realized that they were the Three Stooges, all of them grasping to be some type of leader with their messaging that emphasized fear and compliance and if you failed you would be relegated to restrictions, the irony was we already were so at some point what more can you do?  When I began to listen to their messages and the other crackpot Mike DeWine of Ohio I learned early on that none of them had a fucking clue.  Look to the West Coast and listen to Newsom and Inslee who actually ran for President, and no loss there clearly.  The most interesting was that while all of them had varying levels of tone and advocacy to ensure the public’s cooperation you underneath realized that the message was the same – be afraid, be very afraid.  What they failed to do was actually have any real testing, tracking, tracing and treatment plan. They knew by shouting numbers, making threats and promises that it will get worse they seemed to think that being a bully was the way to somehow make Covid go away.  My favorite here was Murphy saying repeatedly, “Don’t be a knucklehead” while constantly demonstrating what that was with his rambling bullshit that could never be clearly proven, numbers that mad little sense and just the clear copying of Cuomo as the leader of the tribe.  It was as if we are living on the island of lost boys – Neverland. And well that was no utopia and there is no Peter Pan.

When you look to the countries, largely those run by women, it was a much faster progress with regards to all the elements that manage a crisis, planning, communication, cooperation and of course clear established goals in which to meet them.   I knew from looking at the way the announcements were set that regardless we had only a 90 day window, it would be “over” by the 4th of July and that in the interim lives would be destroyed and the economy crushed versus the virus.   Men do that they crush it That is a man’s way.  Never did I hear a voice from in the field sitting adjacent to these men to add resonance and personal experience.  I saw news reports that hysterical health workers fearing for their lives, crying and of course killing themselves over the stress of the failures of the same men crushing it trying to figure out how to have a well thought out plan to deliver supplies and in turn not crush them with patients.  Well they failed on that count as well.  If they believe this was a success then they also believe in fairies.   If any of these idiots are re-elected then I fear for us all.

Then the idiocy of the general public, sending food, the donation of supplies to supplement the ones they lacked, the flying of Blue Angels and let’s not forget the nightly cacophony of clapping, banging pots and making noise to show support. I cannot believe that this will end but why it was in the first place also bothered me as this is a for profit industry and the public facilities where they dumped, yes dumped, most patients were so underfunded, so badly managed and so poorly prepared that I am not sure why we are clapping any of this instead also taking to the streets to demand that while defunding the Police, fund public health. For if we did some of this death may have been prevented.  Then again that would require intelligence and planning such as establishing testing protocols for the most at risk, quarantining them first and in turn having a staggered type of work schedule, to reduce commuting, allow business to function with the limits, the ones they have now only with clear guidelines in place. What is working now would have worked then it was just that they had no way to test the population and we know that the majority of people have not been tested who never showed symptoms nor were sick at all at any time during this lockdown.  So welcome to the doll house.

Today begins the next big phase and frankly what I saw this weekend was alarming, the lack of physical distancing, the lack of PPE and of course overall behavior that made me think the protests were safer to congregate among.  And at least their messaging was clear and concise.

This is from an EMT who I think says it all and reminds us that we are not in a second wave we are in the third wave, a wave comes and goes as all do, some are more powerful and each month the waves were smaller in nature but the water is not flat, it is not calm and it is still flowing every day.  Water does that until it dries out.  We ain’t anywhere near shore yet.  Crush it? Fuck no we just dented it.

Voices from the Pandemic
‘Heroes, right?’
Anthony Almojera, on being a New York City paramedic and the injustices of covid-19
By Eli Saslow
The Washington Post
June 21, 2020

Nobody wants to know about what I do. People might pay us lip service and say we’re heroes, but our stories aren’t the kind anyone actually wants to hear about. Kids in this country grow up with toy firetrucks, or maybe playing cops and robbers, but who dreams of becoming a paramedic? That’s ambulances. That’s death and vulnerability — the scary stuff. We’re taught in this culture to shun illness like it’s something shameful. We’d rather pretend everything’s fine. We look the other way.

That’s what’s happening now in New York. We just had 20,000-some people die in this city, and already the crowds are lining back up outside restaurants and jamming into bars. This virus is still out there. We respond to 911 calls for covid every day. I’ve been on the scene at more than 200 of these deaths — trying to revive people, consoling their families — but you can’t even be bothered to stay six feet apart and wear a mask, because why? You’re a tough guy? It makes you look weak? You’d rather ignore the whole thing and pretend you’re invincible?

Some of us can’t stop thinking about it. I woke up this morning to about 60 new text messages from paramedics who are barely holding it together. Some are still sick with the virus. At one point we had 25 percent of EMTs in the city out sick. Others are living in their cars so they don’t risk bringing it home to their families. They’re depressed. They’re emotionally exhausted. They’re drinking too much. They’re lashing out at their kids. They’re having night terrors and panic attacks and all kinds of outbursts. I’ve got five paramedics in the ground from this virus already and a few more on ventilators. Another rookie EMT just committed suicide. He was having trouble coping with what he was seeing. He was a kid — 23 years old. He won’t be the last. I have medics who come to me every day and say, “Is this PTSD I’m feeling?” But technically PTSD comes after the event, and we’re not there yet. It’s ongoing stress and trauma, and we might have months to go.

Do you know how much EMTs make in New York City? We start at $35,000. We top out at $48,000 after five years. That’s nothing. That’s a middle finger. It’s about 40 percent less than fire, police and corrections — and those guys deserve what they get. But we have three times the call volume of fire. There are EMTs on my team who’ve been pulling double shifts in a pandemic and performing life support for 16 hours, and then they go home and they have to drive Uber to pay their rent. I’m more than 15 years on the job, and I still work two side gigs. One of my guys does part-time at a grocery store.

Heroes, right? The anger is blinding.

One thing this pandemic has made clear to me is that our country has become a joke in terms of how it disregards working people and poor people. The rampant inequality. The racism. Mistakes were made at the very top in terms of how we prepared for this virus, and we paid down here at the bottom.

It started around the middle of March when the call volume began to spike in the poorer neighborhoods. The stay-at-home order in New York hadn’t even gone into effect at that point. Trump was telling us he had everything under control. The mayor was saying we had great health care, and we wouldn’t get hit as bad as other countries, so we should keep on going to the movies. But for us, it was wheezing, trouble breathing, heart palpitations, cardiac arrest, cardiac arrest. This virus stresses out the heart in a bunch of different ways. I’d look at our dispatch screen sometimes and see 30 possible cardiac events happening at any one time across the city, mostly in the immigrant neighborhoods. It felt like watching a bomb go off in slow motion. You had time to see who was going to get hit and who had the ability to escape. I saw in Manhattan, on the East Side, people clearing out of the city to set up shop in the Hamptons or rent property upstate. The business class packed up their computers and went off to work elsewhere. Meanwhile, the rest of us were huddling with no ventilators, like fish in the barrel.

It got so quiet sometimes that all you could hear were our sirens. The most 911 calls we’d ever had was back on September 11th, and we broke that record every day for two weeks straight. My station is right in Brooklyn’s Chinatown, so it’s a lot of new Chinese immigrants, sometimes 10 or 12 people living in a small place. They tend not to call 911 unless its absolutely necessary, but they were calling. One woman was apologizing for bothering us while we were trying to get a pulse back on her uncle. The Dominicans and Puerto Ricans in Sunset Park got hit hard. Sometimes those families will pray over you while you’re doing CPR. The Middle Eastern neighborhoods in Bay Ridge got hit. The African American communities, where hypertension is a big thing. The nursing homes in Far Rockaway. The housing projects in East Flatbush. We weren’t carrying too many stretchers into the fancy brownstones.

I’m a lieutenant and vice president of the union, so I cover a big area, and I mostly go to the big traumas. I grew up in Brooklyn, and I know every street in this city. I can whip it. Doesn’t matter where the call is. I’m two minutes out. I had one guy with covid who was talking to me in his fifth-floor apartment. He was breathing heavy, so we loaded him on the stretcher, and by the time the elevator hit the lobby, he didn’t have a pulse. I went to another high-rise for an unresponsive elderly woman, and then I realize, two days before we were in the same place because her husband had dropped. Both of them died. We sometimes had 400 emergency calls sitting on hold. People were waiting hours for an ambulance on the more minor stuff. I pronounced more deaths in the first two weeks of April than I have in my career.

I got one call at the height of the madness, another cardiac arrest, and it was a Latin guy, young guy, unresponsive and passed out in a room with bunk beds. There wasn’t enough space to work, so we dragged him out into the living room to start giving him CPR. This guy had no pulse. That’s clinical death, but biological death doesn’t come until about six minutes later. That’s our window to bring you back. That’s why we do this job. Now this guy was 31. He was strong, healthy. His mother told us he’d just gone out. As a medic, you hear that and your eyes start to get big. It’s like, okay, maybe this is one we can save.

It was four guys and me. That’s the crew. The two EMTs were bagging him up to get oxygen in his lungs. The medics were starting to intubate and calculating the meds. Everything they can do for you in a hospital, EMS brings to you. We carry 60 medications. We hook up the heart monitor. It all happens so fast, and there’s barely time to talk. It’s scalpel, needle, put in the IV, pace it, shock it, check on the heart rhythms. It’s like a symphony, and you have to know your part.

The team kept working, and I went over to get information from the mother. There was a little girl standing behind her, 7 years old, and it turns out she’s the daughter. They told me he’d been sick four or five days, but he worked at a bodega and he couldn’t afford to take off. He’d come home from work and collapsed a few minutes later. Now I’m getting upset. Here we’re supposed to be this great society, and this guy can’t even miss one paycheck. There’s no safety net. The system we have is broken, and this 7-year-old is seeing her dad get CPR. We kept working. After a few minutes, we got a pulse back. I told the family: “He’s not out of the woods yet, but we might have a shot here.” We rushed him into the truck and over to the hospital, and then he died a while later.

I did 14 cardiac arrests that day. I didn’t save anybody.

The thing about being a paramedic is you need to have some reservoir of hope. This job is the ultimate backstage pass. It can make you believe in humanity, but it can also suck the humanity out of you. You see death, suffering — grief in its rawest forms. I’ve been shot at on this job. I’ve been beaten and cursed at. But then every year, we go to the Second Chance Brunch, and we get to meet some of the people we saved. There’s no drug on the planet like that. There’s no job that matters more. It keeps you going. But then we came into this virus, and we weren’t bringing people back. The virus kept winning. It always ended the same way.

I’d go park the truck at the beach after a double and try to calm myself down and gather my thoughts. I’ve gained weight during this pandemic. I don’t sleep well anymore. Emotionally, I’ve been feeling a little numb. They teach you as a Buddhist that life is suffering, and I believe that. You have to stay in the suffering. You can’t deny reality and turn the other way.

I’ve been in therapy for 17 years, and lately what keeps coming up is that reservoir of hope. It’s starting to feel more and more empty. Our call volume has been down for the last month, but I’m worried it won’t stay there. I don’t have that much faith in what we are anymore. America is supposed to be the best, right? So why aren’t we united at all? Why aren’t we taking care of each other? The virus is hanging around, waiting for us to make more mistakes, and I’m afraid that we will.

False Gods and Idols

Right now we are suddenly worshipping Medical Professionals and other first responders along with Grocery clerk, errand runners and other lowly paid individuals who are now defined as “essential workers” who are the lowest rung on the economic ladder other than Physicians who at least have some higher education other than that no.  Remember when they told you that having a degree would enable you to earn more well it depends on the degree and when the shiny keys are thrown in your direction. Well right now they are being literally thrown to the Valet and he/she is in charge of your survival. Remember to tip well.

Remember STEM? Remember Student Tests and the importance of evaluating Teachers based on the students performance of said tests? How is that working for you now home schoolers?  And it appears that online learning has been a big bust. From special needs to English language learners to available broadband this was another farce exposed in the “wealthiest” country in the world.  Shocking, no not really.  Remember the fad that was going to be free online college learning? I do and what happened there? Oh nothing.  And all of that may be for naught. Big duh.

I was and to some extent still want to teach just a sub as I loathe the politics and bullshit of what has become Education. It always was a pink collar profession and in turn women ran the school house and we know what bitches unhappy women are so go figure.  Then Daddy or literally the token female Administrator who was also a bitch had to run the school like a business with no training or education in business so it was clearly why education was a hot mess as you cannot be both a Teacher or Businessperson.  Kind of like Trump as Business person/President.

I got nothing good to say about my experience in Education other than many of the students who never ceased to amaze me in ways that I still relish and cherish.  How is that home school going with no play time, no music, no breaks what.so.ever. Welcome to the school room. Teachers are heroes!

Now the new focus is on STEM and right now that is a fucked up industry on its own other than the big three and even Apple I wonder how they will pull out of this when the tariffs and hating China kick in when this ends.   That timeline is coming and being done quietly behind closed doors.  Meanwhile in the Valley of Doom they are coming to terms with their bullshit of handing money over to a bunch of idiots who are rebranding how to bag groceries, wash your hair and walk across the street.  To that I say good luck and good bye.

But they will always be ahead of the game as they play it better than anyone and this column in the New York Times highlights a great deal of news coming out of this pandemic and what the Valley is doing to aid this crisis. Its not but it is staffing underpaid and unemployed folks to run and get coffee for someone to afraid to do it themselves.

And of course posted yesterday, Laughter is the Best Medicine, about how Nurses laugh at you.   And there are many many earlier posts in the blog that shares one story after another about medical malpractice and negligence;  For the record there are many happening right now as they are in chaos and they were placed there by the for profit organizations who ran them like some sort of experiment in science that FAILED. And many are laying off personnel while shutting doors to others as a way of balancing the budget. EPIC FAIL.

The stories that will come out of this with many being sent home not tested to end up sick and making others sicker to those intubating patients and doing so poorly, untrained and well then neglected or even unnecessarily as it was easier than putting them on an Oxygen regimen and treating with meds and quality care.. again it should be thought of as a last resort will also be debated.  Of course the infamous death panels are now really happening so that worked out in Trump’s favor to decimate the ACA!

Now with that do I want us to go vigilante on medical professionals? No just quit the idolizing and in turn respect them, listen to them and in fact try to figure out how we can fix this broken mess in a way that it will never happen again.  But it will ask anyone who has ever been in hospital and experienced first had the neglect, the abuse, the plain shitty care.  We are legion so when a Covid victim who was a Physical Therapist here in NYC refused to go to hospital, Mt. Sinai, came up with a system of checks and video conferences on those released patients and out of 35 only one was readmitted so there is one good story out of this. But again when an employee refuses to be admitted what does he know that we don’t.  They are dumps.

As coronavirus fears grow, doctors and nurses face abuse, attacks

By Mary Beth Sheridan, Niha Masih and Regine Cabato
The Washington Post April 8, 2020

It’s hard enough being a doctor in the midst of the coronavirus pandemic. But Sanjibani Panigrahi, a psychiatrist at a government hospital in western India, now finds her own neighbors turning against her.

“We are sure you have corona,” one woman recently shrieked at her, she says, — part of a torrent of abuse from residents at her apartment complex. “We will not allow you in the building.”

In some cities, health-care workers are earning standing ovations for the long, life-risking hours they’re putting in to battle the coronavirus. But in others, they’re facing discrimination and even attacks.

In Mexico, Colombia, India, the Philippines, Australia and other countries, people terrified by the highly infectious virus are lashing out at medical professionals — kicking them off buses, evicting them from apartments, even dousing them with water mixed with chlorine.

The culprits are a minority of the population. But Mexican state authorities are so worried that they’ve arranged special buses for nurses. In parts of Australia, hospitals are urging nurses not to wear their uniforms in public, to avoid attacks.

Last week, Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte ordered police to protect health workers after reports of assaults — including one in which someone splashed bleach in a hospital employee’s face.

The hostility has been a shock to medical professionals already under immense strain. Scores of doctors and nurses around the world have died after being infected with the coronavirus. In many countries, health workers are struggling with a lack of basic protective equipment, such as masks.

“I understand people are afraid, but abusing doctors is not okay,” Panigrahi said by phone from the industrial town of Surat. “We are at risk more than them.”

In her case, the harassment ended after local police and politicians intervened, Panigrahi said. Her neighbors apologized, saying they had been frightened by news about the virus.

Coronavirus lockdowns across Latin America send Venezuelan migrants back to their broken homeland

But other health professionals continue to be stigmatized.

A doctors’ association in Delhi wrote to the central government that health workers were being evicted by landlords over their work. “Many doctors are now stranded on the roads with all their luggage, nowhere to go, across the country,” the association said.

“DEEPLY ANGUISHED,” the country’s health minister, Harsh Vardhan, tweeted in response to such reports. “All precautions are being taken by doctors & staff on #COVID2019 duty to ensure they’re not carriers of infection in any way.”

Authorities say the attacks reflect misunderstanding of the virus and the strict hygiene maintained by hospitals to limit its spread.

In one jarring incident, a man allegedly shot an ambulance driver last week in Quezon province in the Philippines. The assailant was worried the vehicle was going to enter a subdivision and spread the virus, the hospital said.

The Peter Paul Medical Center of Candelaria said its ambulance driver was transporting hospital personnel, not coronavirus patients. “Moreover, proper cleaning and disinfection of the vehicle is done on a regular basis,” the hospital said.

The driver survived, with a finger wound.

Scattered attacks have occurred in many parts of the world, including the United States. A nurse in Chicago told the local ABC7 TV channel last week that she had been punched in the eye on a public bus by a man who accused her of spreading the virus.

“Going to and from work in my scrubs, I often watch people take two steps back away from me” — and not just because of social distancing, she told the station, speaking on the condition that she not be identified. “I think the concern is that any health care provider is contagious themselves.”

Authorities worry such fears could erupt in violence, not just against health professionals but medical facilities.

Protesters in Abidjan, the commercial capital of Ivory Coast, tried to destroy a coronavirus testing center under construction on Monday. Videos on social media showed people ripping planks of wood off the structure as police fired tear gas canisters.

Some told reporters they did not want a treatment facility so close to their homes. “They want to kill us,” one told Reuters.

Health Ministry officials said the center was not even designed to treat patients with covid-19, the disease the virus causes, but rather to test for the virus.

Mexican factories boost production of medical supplies for U.S. hospitals while country struggles with its own coronavirus outbreak

Medical professionals worry the attacks and insults could demoralize health workers just when they’re most needed.

“If we continue to harass them, more of them will quit their jobs, and our health-care system would be in danger,” said Reigner Antiquera, president of the Alliance of Young Nurse Leaders and Advocates in the Philippines.

In Mexico, suspicion of nurses is so widespread that many have stopped going to work in their uniforms.

Maria Luisa Castillo, a 30-year nursing veteran, has worn her white uniform proudly. But on a recent afternoon, after working the daytime shift at Guadalajara’s Civil Hospital, it proved a liability. She was standing alone at a bus stop. A bus approached, she tried to wave it down, and it zoomed on by — to the next block, where it stopped and deposited passengers.

“It was clear they didn’t want to pick me up,” the 51-year-old nurse said.

She was among at least a half-dozen nurses in western Jalisco state who have filed complaints of discrimination or other harassment in recent weeks. In response, the state government is providing free transportation for nurses, along with face masks.

Coronavirus on the border: Why Mexico has so few cases compared with the U.S.

Further north, in Durango state, officials summoned bus companies to explain that there was no health risk in transporting health workers.

“We see how in Italy a nurse leaves her home to go to work and people applaud,” said Fernando Ríos Quiñones, a spokesman for the state health department. “But here we see these sad situations.”

He said special buses were now dropping employees off at hospitals, and taxi drivers were offering 30 percent discounts to doctors and nurses.

Sandra Alemán has heard the advice: Don’t wear your uniform in public. But last Friday, while driving to a public hospital in the city of San Luis Potosi for the night shift, the 32-year-old nurse stopped at a convenience store for a cup of coffee. As she was leaving, she said, some children hurled juice and soda at her, yelling, “Covid! Covid!”
AD

When Aleman scolded the children, she said, their mother slapped her in the face. As she attempted to run away, she said, she fell and fractured a finger.

She’s now feeling something she never experienced in her nine years on the job: fear of going out in public in her uniform. Nonetheless, she said, she plans to return to her job.

“When I recover, I’m going back,” she said.

Hello? 911

There is a show on Fox right now called 911 and it portrays the call center as a logical reasonable place where the responders are intelligent, calm and rational and relay the appropriate information to the Police or other Emergency service individuals aka “First Responders” to the site to resolve the situation.  It’s a TV show.

When one reviews the number of 911 calls made, including the absurd one made my the Starbucks employee there was a point that the 911 Operator could or should ask appropriate questions to ascertain level of risk, danger and urgency.   This then is clearly typed into a screen and should be reiterated back to the caller to once again ascertain level of risk, danger or sense of urgency.  Let us not forget people call 911 for reasons that are less than urgent and in turn are pranks that too can contribute to further problems.  911 is there for a reason and SOMETIMES it does. And sometimes it doesn’t. 

I have numerous stories about how 911 Operators have misreported and added information to the call that in turn is relayed with even more information to the Police.  A good example of that was Tamir Rice where the caller was quite clear it was a child with what appeared to be a FAKE (toy) gun.  Then we have this horrific story about a laughing 911 Operator.    Or how about I ain’t got time for this.   Or how about this 911 Operator who tells you to quit whining!  Or how about going to the wrong address or again this story that I have reprinted below as it all started here.

So while you were all going indignant at Starbucks over the worst failure to communicate a young  boy called 911 several times as he lay dying and guess what the Police did nothing. He was crushed to death.   No mass shooting, not shot in the street but allowed to die while a Patrol car sat idly by.  Yes where is the outrage?  Oh wait its where you get your double latte.

Police responding to dying student’s 911 call stayed in their patrol car, body cam videos show
by Herman Wong and Lindsey Bever
The Washington Post
April 212016

Ohio teen called 911 twice as he was being crushed to death

Officers responding to a 911 call from a high school student trapped and dying in his minivan stayed in their patrol car after arriving on campus, according to body camera videos released by Cincinnati police Friday.

The video comes a week and a half after the death of sophomore Kyle Plush. Hours after the officers’ unsuccessful search, the 16-year-old was found dead by his father in a Honda Odyssey. Cincinnati police, as well as the Hamilton County prosecutor’s office, have launched investigations to try to determine what went wrong — both inside the van and at the 911 call center.

“We owe the Plush family and the public a detailed and comprehensive explanation of everything that has been done, recommendations made and actions taken at the 911 center that could have had any bearing on the practices that may have contributed to this tragedy,” Cincinnati Mayor John Cranley (D) said in an April 12 statement.

When the teenager called 911 on April 10, he knew his situation was dire.

He did not tell authorities what had happened to him when he apparently used an automated assistant on his smartphone to make the call Tuesday outside Seven Hills School in Cincinnati. He said only that he was trapped in his minivan and could not hear them — no doubt hoping they could still hear his cries for help.

“Help, help, help, help,” he told the dispatcher, according to 911 audio obtained by The Washington Post. Then he let out a scream: “Help!”

The teen, who seemed to be laboring to breathe, kept asking for police — briefly pausing between words to try to catch his breath.

The dispatcher repeatedly asked the teen where they could find him.

[A mother found her 2-year-old ‘frozen’ on their front porch on a bitterly cold day]

“I can’t hear you,” the teen said. Distant banging could be heard in the background. “I’m in desperate need of help. … I’m going to die here.”

“Help —” he said once more, then the call abruptly ended.

Five minutes later, at 3:21 p.m., police responded and searched the area near the private school on Red Bank Road but did not see the teen, according to a statement from the Cincinnati Police Department.

In a conversation between the dispatcher and a deputy, the dispatcher said that it had been difficult to hear the teen, saying he sounded “kind of far away from the phone.” The dispatcher said she could hear banging in the background and someone saying, “Help, help, I’m stuck.” The authorities then discussed whether the 911 call might have been a prank.

In the two newly released videos, one from each officer, the cameras captured the immediate area in front of the windshield as the police entered the parking lot and drove around. At one point, an officer can be heard saying, “I don’t see nobody, which I don’t imagine I would.” Neither officer exited the vehicle at any point while the body cameras were recording.

The videos run for slightly longer than three minutes each. The Cincinnati Enquirer reported that police documents said officers were on the scene for 11 minutes.

According to Cincinnati police policy, body cameras must be activated when “officers arrive on-scene” and may be deactivated when officers have finished “clearing the call for service.”

Lt. Steve Saunders, a police spokesman, said the department had no additional comment because an internal investigation is underway.

Nearly six hours later, Kyle’s father found him unresponsive in the vehicle, police said. First responders rushed to the scene but could not revive the teen, and he was later pronounced dead.

“Horrific, horrific situation to come across as a parent,” Saunders said Thursday in a phone interview.

The Enquirer reported that a law enforcement source it did not name told the newspaper that the teen had climbed onto the rear bench seat in the family’s minivan. The teen was trying to reach his tennis equipment, according to the newspaper, when the seat “flipped up and over toward the back hatch, pinning him upside down beneath the seat.”

The Hamilton County Coroner’s Office said in a statement that preliminary autopsy results showed that Kyle died of “asphyxia due to chest compression.”

“This was a horrific tragedy. What I say is that we share in their heartbreak around this,” Cincinnati Police Chief Eliot Isaac said during a news conference. “Police officers, firefighters and even our emergency dispatch personnel — you get into this because you want to help. Something went wrong here and we need to find out why we weren’t able to provide that help that we hoped we could have.”

Cranley called the circumstances of Kyle’s death “devastating” and said they “raise concerning questions about our city’s emergency 911 system and police response. While it is unclear if there is wrongdoing by the city in this tragedy, we have a profound responsibility to find out.”

Police in Cincinnati are investigating the death of Kyle Plush, 16, who was crushed to death by a seat in his minivan while pleading for help from 911 operators (Reuters)

After Kyle’s frantic call for help, a dispatcher tried to call him back — but the teen was not able to answer his phone.

As heard in the 911 audio, the teen’s phone rang and rang, then the call went to his voice mail: “Hello, this is Kyle. I’m not available right now. I’ll get back to you as soon as I can.”

Then, at some point, Kyle called police a second time.

During that call, which lasted several minutes, he sounded weaker and something could be heard creaking in the background as the teen took breaths. He then told the dispatcher to pass along a message after his death.

“I probably don’t have much time left, so tell my mom that I love her if I die,” he said. “This is not a joke. This is not a joke. I’m trapped inside my gold Honda Odyssey van in the sophomore parking lot of Seven Hills [unintelligible]. Send officers immediately. I’m almost dead.”

“Can you hear me?” the teen asked.

“Hey Siri,” he prompted his phone.

“Hey Siri.

“Hey Siri.

“Hey Siri.

“Hey Siri.”

But his pleas went unanswered.

Authorities said responding officers, who were on the scene at the time, never received the detailed information from Kyle’s second 911 call. The dispatcher who took that call, identified as Amber Smith, has been placed on administrative leave pending an internal investigation, police said.

Authorities said that a classmate called Kyle’s parents late last Tuesday, saying that he did not show up for a scheduled tennis match.

The teen’s parents then used an app to track his cellphone and called the police, reporting that their son was missing, police said.

Just before 9 p.m., a passerby also called authorities from the school, saying that a man was running around the parking lot, screaming, “Call 911.” The caller said he could hear “loud bangs” and could see cars parked and people walking around, according to the police audio.

Then another caller, who identified himself as a night-shift worker at the school, called police to report that the teen, who was unresponsive, was trapped in the van — “turned over in his seat and stuck.”

“He’s been there for a while,” he said.

Isaac, the police chief, told reporters that upon arrival, responding officers found Kyle in the van, “not breathing and unresponsive.”

A Honda spokesman told the Associated Press that the vehicle involved in the incident was a 2004 Honda Odyssey. Although there was a recall last year on seats in some Odysseys, the spokesman said there were no such recalls for the model Kyle was in.

“Our hearts go out to the victim’s family during this difficult time,” Honda spokesman Chris Martin said, according to the Associated Press. “Honda does not have any specific information from which to definitively determine what occurred in this incident.”

Seven Hills School said in a statement Thursday that students and staff members are “grieving the loss of this beloved member of our school family.” It described Kyle as “a young person of keen intelligence, good humor, great courage,” adding that “we feel this loss profoundly.”

The school said it could not comment further, citing the ongoing investigation.

D for Dangerous

I read this in the Atlantic Wire and went “wow really?”  Well no I didn’t.  After spending the better part of the last few years pointing and laughing at the debacle called the Affordable Care Bill, which does nothing with regards to 2 out of the 3 parts of the name. Bill yes as we will see plenty of them.

And then I went to catch a bus today and saw a major accident that right now I still reel from shock.  A car racing lost control and crashed into a pole then into a cement wall crushing one vehicle and splitting the other car parked into two pieces.  Apparently both driver and passenger are alive but in critical condition,  I had to leave, too many memories and horrors of my own to remain and be the looky lou as one woman did at mine, not even bothering to call 91,  yet spoke to every Police Officer on the scene.  She saw nothing only heard the impact but waddled down to poke her nose into the accident and did NOTHING to save or help me.  I call her a Cunt but the man who did save my life, aggressively pushed for care and stood by and tried to talk to the Officers on the scene who also never laid eyes or hands on me, don’t seem to recall this Gentle-man.  Funny he recalls them and me two years later.

I could not nor would rise up to either of those two, I had to leave.  I knew the song, both the lyrics and the tune to this one and had no desire to repeat it.

And I also knew the drill they would be taken to Harborview Hospital and if not dead by arrival they likely will be with the agents of death there.  Once evidence would be taken to make the lack of investigation easier, they will be placed in the dumpster or thrown out to families confused, frightened and intimidated by the goon squad staff of “social workers” employed by Harborview to cover up their incompetence and laziness.  Know that song too.

So read the article below and pray you never need help of any kind, you won’t get it nor can get it. Few times you use the two conjunctives together – won’t or can’t – but I did today and I don’t feel good about it nor should I but this is Seattle and we have other priorities to care about, human lives no, but the 12th man yes.  Sad. Grim.Pathetic.

AMERICA GETS A D+ FOR EMERGENCY CARE

DANIELLE WIENER BRONNER
America gets a barely-passing grade on overall emergency care, according to a report card issued the American College of Emergency Physicians (ACEP), which is pretty terrifying for those of us who live here and don’t want to die in an emergency.
The overall score is a weighted average of the country’s grades in five categories:

  • Access to Emergency Care (30% towards the total): D-
  • Quality & Patient Safety Environment (20% towards the total): C
  • Medical Liability Environment (20% towards the total): C – 
  • Public Health & Injury Prevention (15% towards the total): C 
  • Disaster Preparedness (15% towards the total): C – 

According to ACEP, the categories are “based on 136 objective measures that reflect the most current data available from reliable public sources.” ACEP adds that these measures “represent factors vital to life-saving emergency care and meet the key criteria of relevance, reliability, validity, reproducibility, and consistency across all states,” which means the U.S. scored a C at best on every meaningful aspect of life-saving emergency care. For context, the D+ score is actually lower than the C- the U.S. scored overall in 2009, the last time the report card was issued.

Though the news overall is somber, some states did see individual improvements. This year, Washington D.C. beat Massachusetts for the top spot overall, and Colorado and Ohio made it into the top ten for the first time. But a number of states also took an unprecedented plunge to the bottom fifth, including Alabama, Montana, Illinois, Alaska and Louisiana. At least those states aren’t Wyoming, which got a flat-out F.

In addition to D.C. and Massachusetts, Maine, Nebraska, Colorado, Pennsylvania, Ohio, North Dakota, Utah and Maryland are among the top ten states in emergency care overall. But the gap between best and worst states has increased:

In 2014, the highest grade received is a B- and the lowest grade is an F. Comparatively, 2009 grades ranged from a B to a D-, reflecting a declining trend in overall state grades and contributing to the overall worsening national grade. While four states received grades falling in the range of a B in both Report Cards, the number of states with a C grade has dropped dramatically. That gap is accounted for by the increase in states receiving D’s.

CNN notes that more people are seeking emergency care while the supply of emergency care-givers has fallen:

The report also highlighted that there were 130 million emergency department visits, or 247 visits per minute, in 2010, and there were 37.9 million visits related to injury, according to the CDC’s National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey: 2010 Emergency Department Summary. From 1995 to 2010, there was a 34% increase in emergency department visits, according to CDC’s data. During this same time period, the supply of emergency departments went down by 11%. 
And that the number of people seeking care is only going to grow
The number of patients visiting emergency departments is likely to increase as baby boomers age and develop more medical problems. And the report projects that with the Affordable Care Act going into effect, millions of people who can’t find physicians who accept their insurance, and who were added to Medicaid, will also seek emergency care. A recent study in Science suggested that Medicaid increases the use of emergency departments.

The ACEP authors have issued a number of recommendations designed to alleviate the situation, including protecting access to emergency care, supporting programs that focus on its importance, and allocating federal funds to disaster preparedness. Now the question is, is our government prepared to invest in change?

Discover WordPress

A daily selection of the best content published on WordPress, collected for you by humans who love to read.

The Atavist Magazine

Creative Non-fiction, Personal Essay, Memoir, Commentary

WordPress.com News

The latest news on WordPress.com and the WordPress community.

Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started